- 标题
- Preface
- 作者
- Isak Beilis
- 时间
- 2020
- pages
- ix–xv
- 原文
- <!-- page: 8 -->
Preface
…and you will hear it, and investigate thoroughly,
and behold, the matter will be found true
(Deuteronomy—Chap. 17)
The electrical arc is commonly defined as an electrical discharge with relatively
high current density and low gap voltage. Electrical arcs occur in vacuum, as well
as in low- and high-pressure gases. An important issue is the origin of a conductive
medium in the electrode gap. In vacuum, the conductive medium is generated by
vaporization of electrode material during arcing. This arc may also be called an
electrode vapor discharge. Even in most cases where a gas is present, electrode
vaporization is the plasma source process in the near-electrode region. Many
phenomena in these arcs are similar to those in vacuum arcs.
The electrical arc was first reported in the nineteenth century after the obser-
vation of a continuous arc between carbon electrodes while measuring carbon
resistance by Petrov in 1802 in Petersburg and by Humphry Davy in 1808 in
London, while experimenting with pulsed discharges. After some applications,
preliminary investigations of the arc were conducted even in nineteenth century and
systematic research was conducted from the beginning of twentieth century, firstly
with graphite and then with metallic electrodes.
Different phenomena were observed in the arcs. Strongly constricted and highly
mobile luminous forms appeared near the electrodes, later called cathode and anode
“spots.” In these regions, the electrical conductivity transits from very high in the
metal to low in the plasma. Curious phenomena were observed, including frag-
mentation of the plasma in at the arc roots, plasma jet formation, and retrograde arc
spot motion in a transverse magnetic field. Retrograde cathode spot motion in
magnetic fields, supersonic plasma jet flow, extremely high electron emission
density at the cathode, and the high current density in the arc root plasma could not
be explained using earlier existing physical models. This was a consequence of the
then limited knowledge of the plasma processes, leading to inadequate assumptions
for the calculated models. Therefore, the behavior of the arc cathode region was
ix
<!-- page: 9 -->
x Preface
considered mysterious for the long even though it was intensively studied. With
time, experimental and theoretical investigations contributed knowledge that
improved our understanding of some of these phenomena.
Improved diagnostic techniques were applied to the near-electrode region pro-
vided new information, but also required further explanations. Numerous investi-
gators contributed experimental and theoretical knowledge. In the second half of
nineteenth century, electrode repulsion, plasma fluxes, and the arc force on the
electrodes were detected and studied by Dewar, Schuster, Hemsalech, Duffield
Tyndall, and Sellerio. Langmuir, Tonks, and Compton developed the theory of the
space charge sheath, and volt–current and plasma characteristics in the arcs in the
first decades of twentieth century. Stark, and then Tanberg, Cobine, Gallagher,
Slepian, Finkelnburg, Maecker, Gunterschulze, Holm, Smith, Froom, Reece, Ecker,
Lee, Greenwood, Robson, Engel, Kesaev, Plyutto, Hermoch, Davies, Miller,
Rakhovsky, Kimblin, Daalder, Juttner, Hantsche, Anders, Goldsmith, Boxman, the
Mesyats group, the Shenli Jia group and many others significantly contributed to
different aspects of the electrode and plasma characteristics of electrical arcs. The
understanding of observed arc behavior, its characteristics in different regions of the
electrode gap expanded with the progress of plasma science, especially after 1960
in low-temperature plasma, plasma fusion, and astrophysics.
This book consists of four main parts that describe progress in study of cathodic
arc phenomena. It began with the early separate hypotheses of charged particle
generation in the cathode region up to the present time including our own inves-
tigations extending over more than 50 years. The first introductory part contains
five chapters and characterizes the basic plasma and electrode processes needed to
study cathodic arc. Plasma concepts and particle interactions in the plasma volume
and at the surface are presented in Chap. 1. Chapter 2 presents the kinetics of
cathode vaporization and mechanisms of electron emissions. The mathematical
formulation of heat conduction for different cathode geometries subjected to local
moving heat sources are considered in Chap. 3. Chapter 4 presents the transport
equations and mathematical formulation of particle diffusion, and mass and heat
transfer phenomena in a multi-component plasma. The plasma–wall transition
including cathode sheath formation is described in Chap. 5.
Part II presents a review of experimental studies of electrode phenomena in
vacuum arcs. Chapter 6 describes the electrical breakdown of a vacuum gap and the
methods of vacuum arc ignition. Chapter 7 reviews cathode spot dynamics, dif-
ferent spot types, and the problem of current density in the cathode spot. The spot
types are described by their physical characteristics as determined experimentally in
contrast to the previous confused numerical classification. The total eroded cathode
mass loss is considered in Chap. 8, and cathode erosion in the form of macropar-
ticles is considered in Chap. 9. Chapter 10 presents data concerning electrode
energy losses and the effective voltage measured during the arc operation. The
repulsive effect in the arc gap discovered in the second half of nineteenth century as
a plasma flow reaction and the further measurements of the electrode force phe-
nomena in vacuum arcs is reviewed in Chap. 11. Chapter 12 describes experimental
investigation of the cathode jets, including jet velocity and ion current. Chapter 13
<!-- page: 10 -->
Preface xi
presents the state of the art of observations of spot motion in transverse and oblique
magnetic fields. Current continuity in the anode region and the conditions for anode
spot formation are described in Chap. 14.
Theory of the cathodic arc is presented in Part III. The evolution of cathode spot
theory starting from the beginning of the twentieth century up to present time is
described in Chap. 15. The progress and weakness of the developed theories are
analyzed. The reason why the cathode spot was considered mysterious is discussed.
The key issue is electrical current continuity from the metallic cathode to the
plasma. In order to explain continuity, charge-exchange ion–atom interactions were
examined, and it was shown that the ion current to the cathode is determined by the
collisions in the dense near-cathode plasma. Consequently, a gasdynamic theory
was advanced (Chap. 16), which consistently considers the cathode and
multi-component plasma processes and determines the cathode spot parameters
using a mathematically closed formulation. This approach describes the parameters
and current continuity at cathode plasma region as functions of the cathode
potential drop using measured cathode erosion rate and current per spot.
The cathode spot parameters for materials with a wide range of thermophysical
properties were investigated. This study includes the cathode spot characteristics for
three groups of materials. (1) Cathode materials with intermediate thermal prop-
erties (e.g., Cu, Al, Ni, and Ti). In cathodic arcs with these materials, the electron
emission flux is comparable to the evaporated atom flux for a wide region of
cathode temperatures. (2) Cathodes with refractory materials are characterized by
larger flux of emitted electrons than the flux of evaporated atoms over a wide range
of cathode temperatures. A modified model using a “virtual plasma cathode” allows
obtaining an electron emission current density lower than the saturated density.
(3) Volatile cathode material (e.g., Hg) forms an opposite case, which is charac-
terized by an electron emission flux much lower than the vapor flux. The modified
model considers an additional plasma layer adjacent to the cathode sheath, which
serves as a “plasma cathode” supplying electrons for self-sustained arc operation.
A general physically closed approach is advanced considering the kinetics of
cathode vaporization and gasdynamic of plasma expansion, which described as a
kinetic theory in Chap. 17. The kinetic theory simultaneously considered atom and
electron evaporation, taking into account conservation laws for particle density,
flux, momentum, and energy in a non-equilibrium Knudsen layer. In the rarefied
collisional Knudsen layer, the heavy particle return flux is formed at a length of few
mean free paths from the cathode surface. A relatively high atom ionization rate is
due to large energy dissipation which produced the high ion fraction in the back
flux. The difference between direct evaporated atom flux and the returned flux of
atom and ions determines the cathode mass loss, i.e., the cathode erosion rate Gk. It
was obtained that the plasma velocity at external boundary of Knudsen layer is
significantly lower than the sound speed. This very important result indicated that
cathode spots operate self-sufficiently only when plasma velocity is lower than the
sound speed, i.e., when the plasma flow near the cathode is impeded.
<!-- page: 11 -->
xii Preface
The cathode potential drop uc was determined by considering the kinetics for
emitted and plasma electrons. Electron emission was considered as electron
evaporation. The electron beam relaxation zone (analogous to the Knudsen layer for
atoms) depends on the electron beam energy, which is increased in the cathode
sheath by euc. The returned electron flux depends on the plasma density and by the
potential barrier in the sheath (uc). Conservation of electron momentum and elec-
tron energy and the quasineutrality condition on the boundary of Knudsen layer
allow determine uc directly. Two principle rules based on necessity of impeded
plasma flow near the cathode and satisfaction to a positive cathode energy balance
at low spot current, which determine conditions of the cathode spot ignition and
spot development. Chapter 18 describes formation of the cathode plasma jet. The jet
begins as a relatively slow plasma flow, initially produced due to difference of
plasma parameters (plasma velocity formation) in Knudsen layer. The plasma is
further accelerated up to supersonic speed, determined by the cathode dense
plasma, and the energy dissipated by electron beam relaxation due to gasdynamic
mechanisms to the expansion region. The calculated plasma velocity agreed well
with the measurements. The potential distribution is not monotonic, but rather has a
hump with a height of the electron temperature.
Transient cathode spots were studied on the protrusions and bulk cathodes. The
nanolife spot parameters, the mechanism of spot operation on film cathodes,
specific spot parameters at large rate of current rise, and the nature of high voltage
arc initiation were also studied.
Cathode spot motion in magnetic fields is studied in Chap. 19. Three important
experimental phenomena are described: (1) cathode spot grouping and (2) cathode
spot retrograde motion, i.e., in the anti-Amperian direction, when the arc runs in a
transverse magnetic field, and (3) cathode spot motion in oblique magnetic fields.
The retrograde spot motion model takes in account the kinetic principle rules of
impeded plasma flow in the non-symmetric total pressure (gas−kinetic+magnetic) in
the near-cathode plasma. The current per group spot was calculated taking into
account that the plasma kinetic pressure is comparable to the self-magnetic pressure
in the cathode plasma jet. The theory showed that the current per group spot and spot
velocity increase linearly with the magnetic field and arc current, and these depen-
dencies agree with experimental observations. Retrograde cathode spot motion in
short electrode gaps and in atmospheric pressure as well as reversed motion in strong
magnetic fields (>1 T) observed by Robson and Engel is described. The observed
acute angle effect and spot splitting in oblique magnetic fields are explained.
Robson’s experimentally obtained dependencies of the drift angle on magnetic field
and on the acute angle are described by this theory by using kinetic principle rules.
Chapter 20 presents a theoretical study of anode spots. An anode spot theory was
developed using a kinetic treatment of anode evaporation and modeling the plasma
flow in the plasma acceleration region. The plasma energy balance was described
considering the Joule energy in the anode plasma, the energy dissipation caused by
ionization of atoms, energy convection by the electric current, and the energy
required for anode plasma acceleration. The anode surface temperature, current
density, plasma density, plasma temperature, and plasma velocity were calculated
<!-- page: 12 -->
Preface xiii
self-consistently. The main result is a significantly lower degree of anode plasma
ionization (10−3 to 5 10−2) than in the cathode plasma, due to mobility of
electrons higher than the ions, which both supports current continuity in the anode
and cathode regions, respectively.
The applications of cathode spot theory are discussed in Part IV. Chapter 21
describes unipolar arcs on the metal elements in fusion devices. The results of
experimental and theoretical investigation (including details of the primary work of
Robson and Thonenmann) are reviewed, beginning from the first reported data. The
specifics of unipolar arcs on nanostructured surfaces in tokamaks are analyzed. Our
own experimental results for a tokamak wall with a thin tungsten coating on carbon
demonstrate the spot motion mechanism which is similar to spots on film cathodes.
Chapter 22 presents the application of vacuum arc plasma sources for thin film
deposition. Novel arc plasma sources were developed in the last decades at Tel
Aviv University. Low macroparticle density in the films was reached by converting
cathode droplets to plasma through their re-evaporations on a hot refractory anode
surface. Arc characteristics (plasma density, temperature) and deposition rate as
functions of the distances to the substrate from the arc axis, gap distance, electrode
configuration, and electrode materials are discussed. A theory was developed to
describe self-consistently transient anode heating and anode plasma generation. The
advantages of the method are compared with traditional deposition approaches.
Another vacuum arc application is microthrusters for spacecraft. Chapter 23
presents the general problems of vacuum arc plasma thrusters, their main charac-
teristics, and their efficiency. Phenomena in arcs with small electrode gaps are
considered, and processes in very short cathodic arcs relevant to thrusters are
modeled. Simulation produced thrust efficiency results. Microthruster devices
operating in space in the last decade are analyzed.
Chapter 24 applies cathode spot theory to laser–metal interaction and laser
plasma generation. Experiments and previously developed theories of laser–target
interaction are analyzed. It is shown that the plasma generated near the target by
laser and the plasma generated in the cathode region of a vacuum arc have similar
characteristics. Both plasmas are very dense and appear in a minute region, known
as the laser spot and the cathode spot, respectively. The plasma interactions with
matter in both cases are also similar. Taking into account a detailed analysis of the
features of the laser spot, a physical model based on a previously presented kinetic
approach of the cathode spot is described by modifying it for the particular features
of laser-generated plasma. The model considers that the net electrical current is zero
in the laser spot, in contrast to the current carried in a vacuum arc cathode spot. The
specifics of target vaporization, breakdown of neutral vapor, near-target electrical
sheath, electron emission from the hot area of the target, plasma heating, and
plasma acceleration mechanism are detailed. The mathematical description and
simulation for different target materials show an unusual new result. The laser
power absorbed in the plasma is converted into kinetic and potential energy of the
plasma particles and is returned to the target and the target surface temperature
calculated, taking into account the plasma energy flux is significantly larger than
that without this flux.
<!-- page: 13 -->
xiv Preface
Finally, Chap. 25 reports about application of cathode spot theory to arcs formed
in different technical devices: low-temperature plasma generators, plasma acceler-
ators, devices using plasma of combustion products, and rail guns that accelerate the
solid bodies. Cathode spots on the electrodes of these devices are explained using
spot theory for film cathodes and considering a plasma flow consisting of lightly
ionized dopants. Transition from a diffuse to an arc mode was modeled, considering
electrode overheating instability with an exponential dependence of the electrical
conductivity on temperature. Plasma accelerator experiments are discussed: A sig-
nificantly larger electron emission current density than that described by the
Richardson law was detected, and the models are analyzed. The contribution of ion
current is demonstrated using the gasdynamic model of the cathode spot, taking into
account the experimentally observed plasma expansion from the spot.
A mathematical approach described the long-time problem of plasma column con-
striction in atmospheric pressure arcs, without recourse to Steinbeck’s minimal
principle. The arc mechanism and the observed arc parameters in rail gun are
explained using cathode and anode spot models. Experimental reduction of the rate
of solid body acceleration can be explained by the calculated arc velocity depen-
dence on applied electrical power, which tends to saturate when the power increases,
due to increasing arc plasma mass needed to support increasing arc current.
The text includes not only the cathode current continuity mechanism usually
published in the spot theories, but also various ideas to understand many different
spot aspects. The studies presented here cannot address all observed arc discharge
phenomena—they cannot be completely explained by the developed theories.
Nevertheless, I hope that the developed models systematically lead to further
research, increase our understanding of different arc spot mechanisms, and reduce
the mystery surrounding them. I hope this book will be useful for researchers in the
physics of low temperature plasma and gas discharges, practicing engineers and
students learning electrical engineering, plasma physics, and gas discharge physics.
I gratefully acknowledge colleagues for useful discussion, help, and support at
various stages of this work. First, thanks to Vadim Rakhovsky who introduced me to
this subject, worked with me during my postgraduate studies, and helped me to
understand the early experiments on near-electrode phenomena conducted in widely
known Veniamin Granovsky’s laboratory. Thanks to laboratory colleagues
N. Zykova and V. Kantsel for helpful direct discussion for the experiment at first stage
of my spot study. I am grateful to Gregory Lyubimov for discussions and nice joint
theoretical work on the electrode phenomena based on the hydrodynamics of plasma
flow. Great thanks to Igor Kesaev, who explain the specifics of his world known
experiments and the difficulties in my way by choosing this confused problem.
Many thanks to the supervisors of a number of All-Union Seminars: Academician
Nikolay Rykalin (heat conduction in solids caused by a moving concentrated heat
source), Academician Vitaly Ginsburg, Anri Rukhadze, Yuri Raizer (general physics
and physics of gas discharges), and Sergey Anisimov (kinetics of solid vaporiza-
tion). I appreciate Oleg Firsov, which noticed about the charge-exchange process
during the discussions and to Boris Smirnov (elementary collisions of plasma par-
ticles), Alexey Morosov and Askold Zharinov (mechanisms of plasma acceleration).
<!-- page: 14 -->
Preface xv
I am grateful to Academician Vladimir Fortov, which initiated and supported the
doctoral work in the department and Academician Gennady Mesyats for support the
presentation of a thesis of Doctor of Science. As a result, I acquired much scientific
experience and broad scientific knowledge, which played an essential role in my
understanding of the many aspects of cathode spot science.
Since January 1992, my investigations were continued in the Electrical
Discharges and Plasma laboratory at the Faculty of Engineering of Tel Aviv
University. My great thanks to Samuel Goldsmith and Ray Boxman for very
important support and efficient joint work at the first stage and for the excellent lab
atmosphere as my work progressed. I gratefully acknowledge N. Parkansky,
V. Zitomirsky, H. Rosenthal, V. Paperny A. Shashurin, D. Arbilly, A. Nemirovsky,
A. Snaiderman, D. Grach, Y. Koulik, Ben Sagi, and Y. Yankelevich for their
contributions at different stages of the investigation in the laboratory. A special
thanks is addressed to Ray Boxman for helpful discussion of my cathode spot
research and English help at the publication stage. I am grateful to Michael Keidar
for our joint work that began at Tel Aviv University, continues presently and whose
discussions give me great pleasure. Many thanks also for his help during processing
of the manuscript. I appreciate Burhard Juttner, Erhard Hantzsche, Michael Laux,
Boyan Djakov, Heinz Pursch, Peter Siemroth, Lorenzo Torrisi, Joachim Heberlein,
and Emil Pfender for their help during my visits to their respective institutions.
Finally, I would like to thank my family, my loved children for being always
patient with me. Greatly I appreciate my wife Galina, supporting my way of life in
the science, for her understanding and taking care of all my needs.
Tel Aviv, Israel Isak Beilis
2020
评论 (0)