Improved models for neoclassical tearing modes and anomalous transport are developed and validated within integrated modeling codes to predict toroidal rotation, temperature and current density profiles in tokamak plasmas. Neoclassical tearing modes produce helical filaments of plasma, called magnetic islands, which have the effect of degrading tokamak plasma confinement or terminating the discharge. An improved code is developed in order to compute the widths of multiple simultaneous magnetic islands whose shapes are distorted by the radial variation in the magnetic perturbation [F. D. Halpern, et al., J. Plasma Physics 72 (2006) 1153]. It is found in simulations of DIII-D and JET tokamak discharges that multiple simultaneous magnetic islands produce a $10\%$ to $20\%$ reduction in plasma thermal confinement. If magnetic islands are allowed to grow to their full width in ITER fusion reactor simulations, fusion power production is reduced by a factor of four [F. D. Halpern, et al., Phys. Plasmas 13 (2006) 062510]. In addition to improving the prediction of neoclassical tearing modes, a new Multi-Mode transport model, MMM08, was developed to predict temperature and toroidal angular frequency profiles in simulations of tokamak discharges. The capability for predicting toroidal rotation is motivated by ITER simulation results that indicate that the effects of toroidal rotation can increase ITER fusion power production [F. D. Halpern et al., Phys. Plasmas 15 (2008), 062505]. The MMM08 model consists of an improved model for transport driven by ion drift modes [F. D. Halpern et al., Phys. Plasmas 15 (2008) 012304] together with a model for transport driven by short wavelength electron drift modes combined with models for transport driven by classical processes. The new MMM08 transport model was validated by comparing predictive simulation results with experimental data for 32 discharges in the DIII-D and JET tokamaks. It was found that the prediction of intrinsic…
Although there have been a few proposals for fusion reactors employing plasmas far out of thermodynamic equilibrium (such as migma and inertial-electrostatic confinement), there has never been a broad, systematic study of the entire possible range of such devices. This research fills that gap by deriving fundamental power limitations which apply to virtually any possible type of fusion reactor that uses a grossly nonequilibrium plasma. Two main categories of nonequilibrium plasmas are considered: (1) systems in which the electrons and/or fuel ions possess a significantly non-Maxwellian velocity distribution, and (2) systems in which at least two particle species, such as electrons and ions or two different species of fuel ions, are at radically different mean energies. These types of plasmas would be of particular interest for overcoming bremsstrahlung radiation losses from advanced aneutronic fuels (eg. ${}^{3}He-{}^{3}He$ , p- ${}^{11}B$ , and p- ${}^{6}Li$ ) or for reducing the number of D-D side reactions in D- ${}^{3}He$ plasmas. Analytical Fokker-Planck calculations are used to determine accurately the minimum recirculating power that must be extracted from undesirable regions of the plasma's phase space and reinjected into the proper regions of the phase space in order to counteract the effects of collisional scattering events and keep the plasma out of equilibrium. In virtually all cases, this minimum recirculating power is substantially larger than the fusion power, so barring the discovery of methods for recirculating the power at exceedingly high efficiencies, reactors employing plasmas not in thermodynamic equilibrium will not be able to produce net power. Consequently, the advanced aneutronic fuels cannot generate net power in any foreseeable reactor operating either in or out of equilibrium. Moreover, D- ${}^{3}He$ can only produce net power when burned in thermodynamic equilibrium, which means that in any possible D- ${}^{3}He$ reactor, the neutrons…
The purpose of the present work is the analysis of equilibrium and stability properties of tokamak plasmas in the presence of macroscopic flow. First, the formulation of the equilibrium problem is reviewed. Toroidal flow produces a modification in the equilibrium profile due to the centrifugal force produced by the rotation in curved geometry. The effects of poloidal rotation are more surprising, since poloidal flow can produce qualitative modifications in the equilibrium. If the flow is of the order of the poloidal sound speed, discontinuous equilibria develop due to the transition between the subsonic and the supersonic solution of the Bernoulli equation. In the presence of transonic (ranging from subsonic to supersonic values) flows, discontinuous equilibria are the only solution of the Grad-Shafranov-Bernoulli system of equations. If the flow is faster than the poloidal Alfvén speed, the Shafranov shift can be inverted and if the plasma is kept in equilibrium by an external vertical field, the separatrix moves to the outboard side of the plasma. Since the poloidal rotation is damped by the neoclassical poloidal viscosity, a new quasi-omnigenous solution for equilibria with large rotation is also derived in order to minimize the flow damping. All equilibrium analytical results are confirmed by numerical solutions obtained with the code FLOW. The presence of flow also greatly alter the stability problem. A $\delta W$ formulation including the effect of arbitrary flow is introduced and implemented in the code FLOS. FLOS is used to study the effect of flow on internal kink modes. Finally, external kink modes are considered in the case of static plasma but flowing walls. The two-stream flow pattern is shown to stabilize the mode for wall velocities in a realistic range for future experiments.
Energy production through the burning of fossil fuels is an unsustainable practice. Exponentially increasing energy consumption and dwindling natural resources ensure that coal and gas fueled power plants will someday be a thing of the past. However, even before fuel reserves are depleted, our planet may well succumb to disastrous side effects, namely the build up of carbon emissions in the environment triggering world-wide climate change and the countless industrial spills of pollutants that continue to this day. Many alternatives are currently being developed, but none has so much promise as fusion nuclear energy, the energy of the sun. The confinement of hot plasma at temperatures in excess of 100 million Kelvin by a carefully arranged magnetic field for the realization of a self-sustaining fusion power plant requires new technologies and improved understanding of fundamental physical phenomena. Imaging of electron cyclotron radiation lends insight into the spatial and temporal behavior of electron temperature fluctuations and instabilities, providing a powerful diagnostic for investigations into basic plasma physics and nuclear fusion reactor operation. This dissertation presents the design and implementation of a new generation of Electron Cyclotron Emission Imaging (ECEI) diagnostics on toroidal magnetic fusion confinement devices, or tokamaks, around the world. The underlying physics of cyclotron radiation in fusion plasmas is reviewed, and a thorough discussion of millimeter wave imaging techniques and heterodyne radiometry in ECEI follows.…
DIVERTING ENERGY FROM ENERGETIC α-particles to waves (α-channelling) would be extremely beneficial for a magnetically confined deuterium tritium fusion reactor. If these waves were to damp on fuel ions, a hot ion mode would result, doubling the fusion power of the reactor at the same confined pressure. Alternatively, if these waves damp preferentially on electrons traveling in one direction, current would be driven. In both cases, the pressure profile could be modified and ash could be removed to advantage. These potentially significant benefits motivate a detailed study of the implementation of α-channelling. This thesis identifies and explores issues in realizing α-channelling, making the following advances: 1. Calculating, through 0-dimensional reactor simulations, the substantial benefit in α-channelling which motivates the subsequent work. 2. Framing the α-channelling problem as a diffusion problem, with absorbing and reflecting boundaries. To develop insight, α-channelling is considered in a 2-dimensional phase space associated with a simple slab geometry. To solve realistic problems we pose α-channelling in the 3-dimensional constants of the motion space associated with particle orbits in tokamaks. 3. Developing a rapid Monte Carlo simulation in constants of motion space to keep track of wave-induced and collisional effects on the energetic particle distribution. This approach is equivalent to the full energetic particle dynamics in the limit of small changes during a single bounce time and diffusive wave-particle interactions. 4. Identifying the wave characteristics necessary to produce the channelling of fect. which we discover are available in a combination of the mode converted ion- Bernstein wave - MCIBW and the toroidal Alfron eigenmode - TAE: 5. Demonstrating how two waves can be combined in a reverse shear tokamak reactor to absorb 2 of the energy from the $93^{\circ}$ of the a-particles ejected!…
Numerical study of plasma relaxation and self-organization in two-dimensional incompressible magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) systems is presented. A large semi-periodic tearing unstable reversed magnetic field configuration in flat Cartesian geometry and a driven tokamak-like kink-unstable screw pinch in helical geometry are considered. Special emphasis is made on the coupling between global and local scales by way of magnetic reconnection. The influence of the global system's size and geometry on the magnetic reconnection phenomenon and associated current sheet dynamics are evaluated in different collisionality regimes. Questions of plas-moid formation by way of current sheet break-up and onset of fast reconnection in a semi-collisional regime are investigated. Visco-resistive, electron and Hall MHD plasma fluid models are employed in the study. In helical geometry, application of Ohmic current drive to the periodic screw-pinch with large axial magnetic field and hollow resistivity profile are shown to result in “sawtooth-like” limit cycle behavior which is independent of the exact initial conditions. Incomplete reconnection saw-teeth, maintaining the value of safety factor q in the central plasma region below unity throughout the cycle, are demonstrated for the first time in numerical simulations. Sensitivity of sawtooth characteristics to a number of plasma parameters is evaluated. The initial value problems described above are solved with an adaptive fully implicit parallel macroscopic modeling code SEL, which is capable of evolving a large range of extended MHD equations. The structure, key features, and thorough testing of the code are described in detail. “Кому как, а мне нравится думать!” М. Жванецкий "A conclusion is the place where you got tired of thinking." Matz's Maxim
In this work, two separate aspects of ideal MHD theory are considered. In the first part, analytic solutions to the Grad-Shafranov equation (GSE) are presented, for two families of source functions: functions which are linear in the flux function $\Psi$ , and functions which are quadratic in $\Psi$ . The solutions are both simple and very versatile, since they describe equilibria in standard tokamaks, spherical tokamaks, spheromaks, and field reversed configurations. They allow arbitrary aspect ratio, elongation, and triangularity as well as a plasma surface that can be smooth or possess a double or single null divertor X-point. The solutions can also be used to evaluate the equilibrium beta limit in a tokamak and spherical tokamak in which a separatrix moves onto the inner surface of the plasma. In the second part, the reliability of the ideal MHD energy principle in fusion grade plasmas is assessed. Six models are introduced, which are constructed to better describe plasma collisionality regimes for which the approximations of ideal MHD are not justified. General 3-D quadratic energy relations are derived for each of these six models, and compared with the ideal MHD energy principle. Stability comparison theorems are presented. The main conclusion can be summarized in two points. (1) In systems with ergodic magnetic field lines, ideal MHD accurately predicts marginal stability, even in fusion grade plasmas. (2) In closed field line geometries, however, the ideal MHD predictions must be modified. Indeed, it is found that in collisionless plasmas, the marginal stability condition for MHD modes is inherently incompressible for ion distribution functions that depend only on total energy. The absence of compressibility stabilization is then due to wave particle resonances. An illustration of the vanishing of plasma compressibility stabilization in closed line systems is given by studying the particular case of the hard-core Z-pinch.
The goal of the Lower Hybrid Current Drive (LHCD) system on the Alcator C-Mod tokamak is to investigate current profile control under plasma conditions relevant to future devices such as ITER and DEMO. This thesis addresses the behavior of Lower Hybrid (LH) waves in the edge and Scrape Of Layer (SOL) of Alcator C-Mod, a compact, high field, high density, diverted tokamak. The results of coupling experiments over a range of plasma parameters in both Land H-mode plasmas are presented. Experimental observations suggest that power absorption in the SOL (from both Ion Cyclotron Heating and LHCD sources) modifies the density profile in the vicinity of the LH launcher, thereby afecting the coupling of LH waves. An analysis of the damage sustained by the LH launcher also shows absorption of the LH waves in the SOL near the antenna. Estimates of the heat flux sustained by the antenna during high power LHCD are in agreement with measurements of the density and temperature increase on flux tubes intersecting the antenna. Power absorption due to high parallel refractive index modes and collisional absorption are not suficient to explain the increase in density and temperature of the plasma in front of the antenna. Experimental observations of the LHCD “density limit” for C-Mod are presented. Bremsstrahlung emission and relativistic electron cyclotron emission from fast electrons in the core plasma drop suddenly above line averaged densities of $1 0 ^ { 2 0 } \ \mathrm { m ^ { - 3 } } .$ well below the previously observed density limit. These experimental data are compared to both conventional modeling, which gives poor agreement with experiment above the density limit, and a model including edge collisional absorption, which dramatically improves agreement with experiment above the density limit.…
Concern surrounds Alfv´en instabilities driven by super-Alfv´enic fusion-born α-particles and their possible consequences for α-particle transport in fusion tokamak reactors. This has motivated work upon the self-consistent calculation of the power transfer from a highly energetic α-particle population to Alfv´en waves and the ensuing nonlinear wave evolution. A Monte-Carlo approach has been developed which allows fast ions to be studied in the presence of low-frequency $( \omega \ll \omega _ { c i } )$ electromagnetic perturbations in a toroidal plasma. Fast particle motion is treated using a guiding centre Hamiltonian description in straight magnetic field line coordinates. The electromagnetic field is modelled as the superposition of an axisymmetric magnetic field and a spectrum of time dependent Alfv´en Eigenmodes (AE), with the perturbed fields accorded two degrees of freedom corresponding to their amplitudes and phase shifts. The model accounts for nonlinear wave-particle interactions but ignores MHD fluid nonlinearities which are small for typical AE amplitudes. Hence both the spatial structure and eigenfrequencies of the AEs are taken directly from linear MHD eigenfunctions. Numerical noise in the system is reduced by considering only those ‘particles’ present in the system that constitute the change in the fast particle distribution function, this being the so-called $\delta f$ technique. Such an approach allows studies to be focused upon an accurate description of those resonant particles which provide a transfer of fast-ion free energy to the unstable AE. The growth in AE amplitude eventually leads to a modification of resonant α-particle orbits and ultimately to the wave itself saturating. Results identify mechanisms of α-particle redistribution and loss in the presence of fixed and self-consistently varying amplitude AEs in large tokamaks such as JET and ITER.
Understanding of the behavior of burning plasmas represents the primary scientific challenge faced by International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) and fusion plasma research, and a necessary step towards the demonstration of fusion as an energy source. In a first-stage fusion reactor, the self-heating is provided by the alphas generated at 3.5 MeV by the deuterium-tritium (D-T) fusion reactions. Furthermore, other energetic particles with energies in MeV range, which depart from Maxwellian distribution, are generated by high-energy neutral beam (NB) injection and/or ion cyclotron resonant heating. These are expected to play a major role in plasma heating and current drive. Therefore, it is very important to study energetic-particle physics theoretically and experimentally in existing fusion experiments. In particular, a good alphas-particle confinement is essential to realize a fusion power reactor. Namely, an important physics subject in fusion plasmas is interaction between energetic particles and thermal background plasma. This nonlinear interaction is important due to high-alpha particle density and alpha-particle instability drive. In ITER, high-energy NB is used to drive a significant fraction of plasma current in addition to plasma heating. Alfvénic and acoustic-type instabilities may be excited by energetic particles in reactor-relevant plasmas such as ITER. These instabilities can cause significant losses of hot energy and particles, which are very harmful for the plasma confinement and the first wall, resulting in deterioration of plasma performance. Alfvénic and acoustic-type instabilities can redistribute energetic-particles and consequently influence the profile of driven current. Also, alpha particles can impact on MHD modes significantly. Fusion alpha particles can potentially stabilize/destabilize internal kink mode and induce monster sawteeth.…
The Spherical Tokamak (ST) concept has become one of the main avenues in magnetic nuclear fusion research since STs successfully demonstrated plasma operation at $\beta = 2 P \mu _ { 0 } / B ^ { 2 } \sim 1$ 1. Next step ST machines aiming at achieving burning plasma conditions in high β plasmas are being planned, such as the Spherical Tokamak Power Plant (STPP) and the Component Testing Facility (CTF). Instabilities of fast particle-driven Alfv´en eigenmodes are often observed in present-day STs. Such instabilities, driven by fusion-born alpha particles as well as by fast ions produced with auxiliary heating schemes, in the next step STs may pose a major problem as these instabilities may afect confinement and losses of the fast ions. A theory of compressional Alfv´en eigenmodes (CAE) with frequencies above the deuterium cyclotron frequency, $\omega > \omega _ { c D } .$ , is developed for plasma parameters of a STPP, and modes in the ion-ion hybrid frequency range, $\omega _ { c T } < \omega < \omega _ { c D }$ , are also investigated in order to assess the potential of diagnosing the deuterium-tritium (D-T) ratio. For the 1-D character of a STPP equilibrium with $\beta \sim 1$ , a ‘hollow cylinder’ toroidal plasma model is employed for studying CAEs with arbitrary values of the parallel wave-vector $k _ { \parallel } = \mathbf { k } \cdot \mathbf { B } / \left| \mathbf { B } \right|$ . The existence of weakly-damped CAEs, free of mode conversion, is shown to be associated with the ‘well’ in the magnetic field profile, $B = B \left( R \right)$ , that can exist at the magnetic axis. A significant part of this thesis focusses on the experimentally observed efects of resonant wave-particle interaction between Alfv´en waves and fast particles in the Mega Amp Spherical Tokamak (MAST) device at the Culham Laboratory, UK, and in the LArge Plasma Device (LAPD) in the University of California, Los-Angeles, USA. New robust experimental scenarios for exciting CAEs in the…
The achievement of sustained nuclear fusion in magnetically confined plasma relies on eficient confinement of alpha particles, which are high-energy ions produced by the fusion reaction. Such particles can excite instabilities in the frequency range of Alfv´en Eigenmodes (AEs), which significantly degrade their confinement and threatens the vacuum vessel of future reactors. In order to develop diagnostics and control schemes, a better understanding of linear and nonlinear features of resonant interactions between plasma waves and high-energy particles, which is the aim of this thesis, is required. In the case of an isolated single resonance, the description of AE destabilization by high-energy ions is homothetic to the so-called Berk-Breizman (BB) problem, which is an extension of the classic bump-on-tail electrostatic problem, including external damping to a thermal plasma, and collisions. A semi-Lagrangian simulation code, COBBLES, is developed to solve the initial-value BB problem in both perturbative (δf) and self-consistent (full-f) approaches. Two collision models are considered, namely a Krook model, and a model that includes dynamical friction (drag) and velocity-space difusion. The nonlinear behavior of instabilities in experimentally-relevant conditions is categorized into steady-state, periodic, chaotic, and frequency-sweeping (chirping) regimes, depending on external damping rate and collision frequency. The chaotic regime is shown to extend into a linearly stable region, and a mechanism that solves the paradox formed by the existence of such subcritical instabilities is proposed. Analytic and semi-empirical laws for nonlinear chirping characteristics, such as sweeping-rate, lifetime, and asymmetry, are developed and validated. Long-time simulations demonstrate the existence of a quasi-periodic chirp ing regime. Although the existence of such regime stands for both collision models, drag and difusion are essential to reproduce the alternation between…